Insights & Info

Insights > Issues that could impact your company’s market value

Issues that could impact your company’s market value

By Generational Equity

Issues that impact business

Business owners are usually unaware how two key issues can negatively impact the market value of their business. These are customer and supplier concentration.

Frequently Generational Equity, part of the Generational Group (Generational.com), work with clients who are justifiably proud of the long-term relationship they have developed with an important client. They rightly point out that the only reason that 50% of their revenue comes from this blue chip, Fortune 500 firm is because of the great service and reliable products they provide.

On the surface this is correct. There is no way a Fortune 500 client is going to establish and maintain a relationship with a key supplier if the product and service are not exemplary; multiple alternative sources abound in the market.

However, from a buyer’s viewpoint, even though this relationship may be annually renewed by written contract, there is substantial risk involved. Keep in mind that a buyer will often skeptically assume that one reason the relationship exists is due to the fact that the company’s owner has a personal relationship with a buyer working for the blue chip company, and that this relationship could disappear if the current owner departs.

How this affects value is debatable. Some dealmakers will tell you that the discount rate (the rate applied to future earnings using the Discounted Cash Flow valuation model) will be significantly higher to adjust for this perceived risk. How high this discount rate goes will be driven by a variety of other factors beyond simply customer concentration; however, buyers regularly tell us that after the issue of inaccurate financials, customer concentration is a key risk factor they are concerned about.

We point this out to our readers so that they can be aware of this issue in advance of presenting their companies to buyers.

Some Examples of This in Action

Let’s assume that you are a buyer and have two equally attractive, growing businesses you are reviewing as acquisition opportunities. One has been growing at a compound annual rate of 10% over the past five years (with annual revenue around $5 million) and, likewise, its profit margins have been steadily improving.

The second company has been growing at a 15% clip and is much larger, generating $15 million with steady margins as well. However, the second company has a customer generating 35% of its annual revenue and accounts for even more of its profits, and has been doing so for years.

Assuming that the owners of both businesses are close to retirement and want to exit, the professional buyer will typically assign a greater risk factor (discount rate) to the second company, even though it is larger and has been growing faster. Now you may say, “But wait, isn’t there intrinsic value to the long-term relationship with the customer generating 35% of revenue? Shouldn’t that likewise be factored into the equation?”

The answer to that question is yes and no. Certainly the profits generated over the past five years will be a key positive when being evaluated. However, the seller’s job (and that of his/her M&A advisor if he/she has hired one) is to convince the buyer that this concentration concern is not an issue and the relationship is based on what the business does, not on the owner’s personal interactions.

This can be a tough item to “sell” to a buyer who might simply say, “OK, sounds good but I am going to acquire the first company because even though it is smaller, generating less revenue/profits, the risks associated with its future are lower.” And, in fact, the upside is greater since obviously there is growth potential in this industry.

The Solution to the Dilemma

The real answer to this predicament is to never allow yourself and your business development people to become complacent with their customer base composition. In fact, when we delve into this with most of our clients facing a customer concentration issue we find the same problem time and time again: Lots of potential customers are out there, but the owner has simply lost his/her drive the last few years and has basked in the benefits of having a repeat customer without realizing the downside impact this could have on the market value of the business.

If you are planning to exit in the next few years, it is vital that you review your customer list with your business development staff and determine if the organization as a whole has become far too complacent in seeking new business.

Having said that, it is clear that in some industries, customer concentration is standard. For example, if you are producing jet aircraft engine parts, odds are good that the list of customers you can approach is relatively limited. And if you are approaching buyers who are already in this industry and are aware of this situation being customary, then the risk associated with your opportunity will not be as critical.

However, in most industries this is not the case and lots of potential customers exist.

The same can also be said of supplier concentration. The world quickly learned about vendor issues when the tsunami hit Japan in March of 2011. U.S.-based companies found out the hard way how risky it is to have a limited number of suppliers located in the same geographic area.

The bottom line is this: To enhance your market value in the eyes of potential buyers, never become content with your customer list and supplier sources. Keep pushing your sales, marketing, and operations staffs to diversify, diversify, diversify! In so doing, you will not only help your company grow the right way, you will enhance both your market value and sale-ability.

Carl Doerksen is the Director of Corporate Development at Generational Equity.

Make an informed decision

The best decisions in life are informed decisions. We release educational business insights like this every week. Subscribe to make sure you don’t miss the latest news, views and analysis.

Success

Success, you have been added to our list.

I quickly recognized that Don was working for Sharpe Mixers above all else, and held our interests above others.
Jay Dinnison, Owner of Sharpe Mixers
Thanks to you, the entire GE team and especially Michael Goss for driving a great valuation, coaching me and driving the process across the finish line. Please let me know if there is anything I can do to support GE going forward. P.S. Given my experience with GE I felt comfortable enough to sign up with Generation Wealth Advisors!
Tom Currier, Former President & CEO, Rackmount Solutions
We were happy to see the interest in our company and what we cherished has not just a valuable company but an important company to the communities we served in.
Larry Moore, Owner, A Company Portable Restrooms
Your wisdom and experience were invaluable to me during this once-in-a-lifetime transaction.
Ralph Noblin, President of Noblin & Associates
We were represented by Michael Goss with Generational. The due diligence was grueling and exhausting, but Michael propped us up and kept us motivated throughout the process. Debi and I continued to ask each other how we could possibly make it through this process without the assistance of Michael. Michael's professionalism and knowledge is absolutely amazing, and we are so blessed to have had him by our side as we made our future dreams come true.
Bob and Debi Lee, Owners of BL Technology, Inc and BL Tl Services, LLC
Through the sale process, Generational brought in several interested buyers and we closed in about 6 months. I am so glad I accepted that invitation to the conference and could not be happier with the whole process. The team at Generational coupled with their knowledge and guidance was so valuable that in the end, I know I could never have done this on my own!
JoAnn Ellis, Owner of Fondren 5 Star Kennels
After attending a conference with GE, I decided that the value they bring would be worth the expense and as soon as I started working with them, I realized that was the right decision. When we started to get LOIs, Fred Zweifel took the lead on the communication and supported negotiations throughout the process, which got tricky as we moved forward. I learned that it can be common for companies to make a great offer then work to erode that price with their discoveries, but Fred and the GE team kept that from happening.
Caroline Connelly, CEO, OptoTest
I am pleased that I was able to work with Andrew Byrd throughout this experience. From the first meeting we had in Minneapolis I felt that I was in good hands. His knowledge and expertise is second to none. He guided the process consistently throughout. I feel lucky that I was pared with Andrew and could not be happier that I chose Generational Equity to handle this major life event. Thank you Andrew and GenEq for everything!
Eric Erlandson, Owner, Action Fastenings, Inc.
I would like to thank you and your firm, Generational Equity, for being our valued advisors in our journey.
Bil MacLeslie, CEO, ipHouse
The professionals at Generational Equity then helped develop a roadmap for enhancing the value of the firm and an evaluation report. This was completed by June 14, 2021. We then developed the Confidential Information Memorandum and put Taylor Studios, Inc. on the market by July.
Generational Equity’s professional staff helped me every step of the way. Their network and professionals are the only reason I sold my company this quickly. For me this is a once in a lifetime sale and I was unfamiliar with the process. I was able to lean on them with questions and concerns.
Betty L. Brennan, President, Taylor Studios
I couldn’t have asked for a better team than Michael and Deborah. We couldn’t have done it without them.
Robert Evans, President and CEO of Mealtracker Dietary Software
Michael worked tirelessly, He followed every lead meticulously and urgently to make sure nothing was missed.
Robert Evans, President and CEO of Mealtracker Dietary Software
Generational Equity’s assistance was invaluable in compiling and marketing our business.
Bil MacLeslie, CEO, ipHouse
I must say that I have never worked with a more driven, competent and focused individual as Don Ho.
Jay Dinnison, Owner of Sharpe Mixers
The process was much more involved than I expected and your help, experience and advice was a big factor in making the negotiations go as smoothly as possible.
Terry D. Wickman, President, Keytroller
I decided to attend the conference and hopefully receive some guidance on how to structure an exit plan of my business. Upon arriving at the conference, I was so impressed with the presentation given by Generational Equity that I set a future appointment that week to discuss the possibility of selling my business with their Senior Managing Director David Robinson.
JoAnn Ellis, Owner of Fondren 5 Star Kennels
I need to say an immense thank you to Don Ho for his stellar work ethic, attention to detail, and tireless effort. Also thank you to the whole crew at GE! Without you, Don could not do such a phenomenal job. We were shooting for closing and funding before the end of 2020, due to the uncertainty of the political landscape and taxes. I am happy to report we closed last week and will be funding tomorrow.
Dr. Caty J. Catron PhD, RN, VA-BC – Owner, Vic The Picc, LLC
We knew it would be a difficult task to have someone really understand our business and our market, prior to researching a possible buyer, so it was imperative that we found someone of your caliber, with definite proven experience in this area.
Rick Nowak, President/CEO, Kurz Electric Solutions, Inc.
The most important contribution I think Ahmad made was with his personality and work ethic. He is sincere, efficient, and very hard working. He was available to me at all times, whether it was for specific detail of the negotiation or just to talk through the bigger picture. He listened, advised, and recommended, but never forced his idea or opinions. In the time we worked together, he became a valued colleague and also a friend.
Salvo Stoch, Founder and CEO of Sleeping Partners
I wanted to write you a quick letter to express our appreciation and our delight on the outcome of helping us through the process of our recent sale. We are very happy with the end result, and are very happy to be able to move forward with all of our future growth plans.
Terry D. Wickman, President, Keytroller
Thank you again for all your guidance and support. Any company will achieve what they intend, if they have you on their team!
Rick Nowak, President/CEO, Kurz Electric Solutions, Inc.
T.D., thank you so much! You are a great leader! I love how you are using your gifts and talents to better others. You are clearly a GREAT COACH! This 3 day session undoubtedly changed the future of our business, and very well may have been the sole catalyst to save my company, my health and my marriage! A genuine “thank you” from the bottom of my heart.
Bryan D. Horn, Owner, Over Under Clothing
We thank you Eric and Generational Equity making our dream come true.
Larry Moore, Owner, A Company Portable Restrooms
Generational Equity educated and informed us – so that we could be on the upside of a good decision (to sell).
Bil MacLeslie, CEO, ipHouse
I wanted to take this opportunity to thank you for all that you have done for us. Not only did you take care of all the aspects of the sale but took extra care to make sure we knew what it looked like every step of the way. I will definitely recommend your company to anyone that is in a position to or looking to exit their business.
Shane and Johanna Kline, Owners of Vision Upfitters
Greetings Mike. Thank you for the captivating and compelling presentation you made at the Phoenix presentation last week. Over many years in business yours was the most informative and well-presented presentation, on any subject, that I have ever attended! Your energy and enthusiasm combined with your concise and captivating support of your positions with easily understood examples and data was compelling.
Pete L.
We had the pleasure of working with Mr. Ahmad Behjati Managing Director, M&A, for Generational Equity during our acquisition of Papa's Dodge in late 2021. Generational Equity and Mr. Behjati represented and marketed Papa’s Dodge. As our primary contact, Mr. Behjati was professional in every facet of this acquisition process, conveying valuable advice most times and assisting us in every step of the process.
Rick Greene of Dobbs Equity Partners LLC
We are very happy with the end result, and are very happy to be able to move forward with all of our future growth plans.
Rick Nowak, President/CEO, Kurz Electric Solutions, Inc.
The help you provided us during each step of this process made us feel very comfortable and confident we were selecting the right approach to transition our Company.
Andy Graham, Vice President, Modern Heating & Plumbing