In 2011, with the financial crisis still fresh in the collective memory of investors, well-known authors and researchers Clifford Asness, Roni Israelov, and John Liew published an article aptly titled “International Diversification Works (Eventually)” in the CFA Institute Financial Analysts Journal.
Their research concluded that “diversification protects investors against the adverse effect of holding concentrated positions in countries with poor long-term economic performance. Let us not fail to appreciate the benefits of this protection.”
Fast-forward to 2019. After 8 more years of sustained outperformance of US equities, it’s clear that many investors have done exactly what this article warned against - failed to appreciate the benefits of international diversification.
It’s particularly true in the US, where two well-known behavioral biases combine to drive this thought process. Recency bias causes investors to focus on the period of time from 2009 to today, during which US markets have outperformed. In addition, familiarity bias is at work, since US investors are more comfortable investing in companies or indices that they know and hear about every day.
This is a mistake. Let’s examine the data from nearly 50 years of global investing opportunities.
It’s December 1989.
The Soviet Union is beginning to disintegrate and George H. W. Bush has just been elected as the country’s 41st president. Your investment in the S&P 500 has done pretty well since January 1970 when you decided to focus on US stocks. In fact, it has returned a total of 790% over that 18-year time period - an impressive CAGR of 11.55%*1.
Then your friend, who has concentrated his portfolio in international stocks, tells you that his total return has been 1,541%.
What? Developed country international stocks have produced a return that’s essentially double that of the US? It seems impossible (particularly in light of recency bias), but it’s true. The MSCI World Ex-USA index outperformed the S&P 500 dramatically for 20 years.
It’s now December 1999.
The tech boom in the US has been in full effect and your investment in the S&P 500 has benefited handsomely. As you and your friend huddle on New Year’s Eve awaiting the meltdown of the world’s power grid when the “Y2K bug” strikes, you compare notes*2.
Your US stock index has returned a whopping 432% during the last decade, trouncing the developed international stock index that eked out only 98%*3. You feel vindicated as the clock strikes midnight and nothing bad happens. Ah, but just wait.
It’s December 2009, and it has been quite a ride.
We’ve gone through the “tech bust” of 2000-2002 and the financial crisis of 2008-2009. Stocks have recovered a lot from their low in March of this year, but the S&P 500 has lost 9% over the last decade*4. Yes, an entire decade with nothing to show for the huge amount of risk you endured. You would have been better off in treasury bonds.
Your friend’s investment in developed international stocks hasn’t done much better, but at least it was a positive return of 17%*5. But, wait - he further diversified his non-US portfolio!
Over the last decade it has become possible to invest in a new asset class - emerging markets. These less-developed countries have stock markets, too. They can be volatile, but they have done very well, returning 154% over the last ten years*6. You retreat into the fantasy of James Cameron’s Avatar to help forget this horrible decade.
So, at this point in time, what works best? US or International investing?
If we compare 40 years of data from 1970 through 2009, there is no significant difference in the returns of US versus international equities. The S&P 500 produced a 9.87% CAGR and the MSCI World ex-USA index returned 9.54%*7. If we include emerging markets, beginning in 1999, international stocks returned 9.89%*8.
International stocks were slightly more volatile, but the additional volatility is largely the result of currency fluctuation, not stock market risk*9. This is, of course, consistent with what financial economists would expect - asset classes with similar risk, over time, must provide similar rates of return.
It’s June 2019.
The S&P 500 has returned just over 200% since the beginning of 2010*10. Developed international markets have only returned 48% and emerging markets have managed a paltry 26%.
Based on everything that we know from almost 50 years of global stock market performance, would you allocate more to US or international stocks? Or would you maintain a global portfolio that’s allocated across countries based on the relative size of their market capitalization?
The answer should be obvious if you can look past recency and familiarity bias.
Michael worked tirelessly, He followed every lead meticulously and urgently to make sure nothing was missed.Robert Evans, President and CEO of Mealtracker Dietary Software
Greetings Mike. Thank you for the captivating and compelling presentation you made at the Phoenix presentation last week. Over many years in business yours was the most informative and well-presented presentation, on any subject, that I have ever attended! Your energy and enthusiasm combined with your concise and captivating support of your positions with easily understood examples and data was compelling.Pete L.
We thank you Eric and Generational Equity making our dream come true.Larry Moore, Owner, A Company Portable Restrooms
We knew it would be a difficult task to have someone really understand our business and our market, prior to researching a possible buyer, so it was imperative that we found someone of your caliber, with definite proven experience in this area.Rick Nowak, President/CEO, Kurz Electric Solutions, Inc.
I quickly recognized that Don was working for Sharpe Mixers above all else, and held our interests above others.Jay Dinnison, Owner of Sharpe Mixers
I couldn’t have asked for a better team than Michael and Deborah. We couldn’t have done it without them.Robert Evans, President and CEO of Mealtracker Dietary Software
The process was much more involved than I expected and your help, experience and advice was a big factor in making the negotiations go as smoothly as possible.Terry D. Wickman, President, Keytroller
Thank you again for all your guidance and support. Any company will achieve what they intend, if they have you on their team!Rick Nowak, President/CEO, Kurz Electric Solutions, Inc.
Generational Equity educated and informed us – so that we could be on the upside of a good decision (to sell).Bil MacLeslie, CEO, ipHouse
We will highly recommend Generational Equity and Musa Jagne to any business owner about to embark on the same process.Karen S. Williams, CFO, BW Manufacturing
I must say that I have never worked with a more driven, competent and focused individual as Don Ho.Jay Dinnison, Owner of Sharpe Mixers
We were happy to see the interest in our company and what we cherished has not just a valuable company but an important company to the communities we served in.Larry Moore, Owner, A Company Portable Restrooms
Your wisdom and experience were invaluable to me during this once-in-a-lifetime transaction.Ralph Noblin, President of Noblin & Associates
I would like to thank you and your firm, Generational Equity, for being our valued advisors in our journey.Bil MacLeslie, CEO, ipHouse
Generational Equity’s assistance was invaluable in compiling and marketing our business.Bil MacLeslie, CEO, ipHouse
We are extremely pleased with the way Generational Equity handled the sale of our company. Your associates, Tom and Chris, did an outstanding job of getting us (me) through the process.Michael J Polarek, President, Paragon Packaging
Bruce and I wanted to take this opportunity to thank Generational Equity for assigning Musa Jagne to our transaction. In Bruce’s words, “Musa did one hell of a job for us!”Karen S. Williams, CFO, BW Manufacturing
I wanted to write you a quick letter to express our appreciation and our delight on the outcome of helping us through the process of our recent sale. We are very happy with the end result, and are very happy to be able to move forward with all of our future growth plans.Terry D. Wickman, President, Keytroller
We are very happy with the end result, and are very happy to be able to move forward with all of our future growth plans.Rick Nowak, President/CEO, Kurz Electric Solutions, Inc.
Tom Staszak is one of the most professional people I have dealt with in my last forty years of business. You’ve got a great group of people and you have built a truly professional organization.Michael J Polarek, President, Paragon Packaging
Thanks again Phil and feel free to have a future client call me if they would like a referral. You are a true professional!Andy Graham, Vice President, Modern Heating & Plumbing
The help you provided us during each step of this process made us feel very comfortable and confident we were selecting the right approach to transition our Company.Andy Graham, Vice President, Modern Heating & Plumbing
The information we learn from customers helps us personalize and continually improve your experience. Here are the types of information we gather.
We receive and store any information you enter on our Web site or give us in any other way. We do not sell or rent your personal information to others without your consent. We use the information we collect only for the purposes sending promotional information, enhancing the operation of our site, serving advertisements, for statistical purposes and to administer our systems. We DO NOT use third parties to provide customer service, to serve site content, to serve the advertisements you see on our site, to conduct surveys, to help administer promotional emails, or to administer drawings or contests, but reserve the right to do so in the future without advance notice.
Generational Equity, LLC’s affiliates are all part of one corporate family, they work with one another and may work together to provide services to you. The sharing of your information among affiliates enables Generational Equity Canada to serve you more efficiently and makes it more convenient for you to do business with Generational Group. Generational Equity Canada is permitted by law to share information with its affiliates. All of our affiliates follow similar privacy policies.
For reasons such as improving personalization of our service, we might receive information about you from other sources and add it to our account information.
Generational Group may license the use of its intellectual property including but not limited to its name, likeness, and logo for the use of affiliated offices. Such affiliated offices may not be owned, controlled, managed, supervised or staffed by employees, officers, or agents of Generational Group. Affiliated offices may be independently owned and operated. For more information about a particular office, please contact Generational Group at its office in Dallas, Texas.
This page may contain other proprietary notices and copyright information, the terms of which must be observed and followed.
Information on this web site may contain technical inaccuracies or typographical errors. Information may be changed or updated without notice. Generational Group may also make improvements and/or changes in the products and/or the programs described in this information at any time without notice.
Generational Group does not want to receive confidential or proprietary information from you through our web site. Please note that any information or material sent to Generational Group will be deemed NOT to be confidential. By sending Generational Group any information or material, you grant Generational Group an unrestricted, irrevocable license to use, reproduce, display, perform, modify, transmit and distribute those materials or information, and you also agree that Generational Group is free to use any ideas, concepts, know-how or techniques that you send us for any purpose.
Our computer system protects personal information using advanced firewall technology.
Information Generational Group publishes on the World Wide Web may contain references or cross references to other products, programs and services that are not announced or available in your country. Such references do not imply that Generational Group intends to announce such products, programs or services in your country. Consult a Generational Group representative for information regarding the products, programs and services which may be available to you.
Generational Group makes no representations whatsoever about any other web site which you may access through this one. When you access a non-Generational Group web site, please understand that it is independent from Generational Group, and that Generational Group has no control over the content on that web site. In addition, a link to a non-Generational Group web site does not mean that Generational Group endorses or accepts any responsibility for the content, or the use, of such web site. It is up to you to take precautions to ensure that whatever you select for your use is free of such items as viruses, worms, Trojan horses and other items of a destructive nature.
IN NO EVENT WILL Generational Group BE LIABLE TO ANY PARTY OR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, SPECIAL OR OTHER CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES FOR ANY USE OF THIS WEBSITE, OR ON ANY OTHER HYPERLINKED WEBSITE, INCLUDING, WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY LOST PROFITS, BUSINESS INTERRUPTION, LOSS OF PROGRAMS OR OTHER DATA ON YOUR INFORMATION HANDLING SYSTEM OR OTHERWISE, EVEN IF WE ARE EXPRESSLY ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES.
Furthermore, all information contained within this website is the property of Generational Group.
Honored to win Investment Banking Firm of the Year 3 years running.
Over 50 awards and counting.
Sign up to receive regular email updates, industry-leading insights and details on complimentary M&A executive conferences in your area from our award-winning team
Success, you have been added to our list.